The back office question comes first
Before comparing screens, answer one question: who keeps the books for these units. If the answer is a bookkeeper, a CPA at year end, or a spreadsheet you already trust, then buying a platform to get a maintenance module means paying for and configuring a ledger you will not use. Owners in that spot usually run the platform for two months, keep using text messages for repairs anyway, and cancel.
If the answer is that your books are a mess and rent collection is manual, the calculus flips. A full platform earns its keep by pulling rent, ledger and leasing together, and the maintenance piece rides along. LeakTicket is not trying to win that owner. It is built for the person whose money side is fine and whose repair side is undocumented.
What a repair record has to survive
A small landlord repair record gets tested in three places: a security deposit dispute, a code enforcement file after a no heat or habitability complaint, and an insurance renewal where the carrier asks about prior water losses. All three care about the same four facts. When was the problem reported, what did it look like, when did someone get access, and when was it fixed.
LeakTicket is organized around those four facts and nothing else. The tenant report carries its own timestamp and the photos the tenant took. The entry notice date and the vendor visit sit on the same ticket. The completion date and the invoice close it. When you pull the unit history two years later, the sequence reads in order without you reconstructing it from a phone.
Running both at once
Plenty of owners land on a hybrid. They keep accounting where it already works and put the tenant facing repair link on LeakTicket, because the link is the part tenants actually touch. Nothing stops you from exporting closed tickets and invoices into whatever ledger you keep, and a monthly export is normal practice for owners who file Schedule E themselves.
If you later grow into a management company with staff, a full platform starts to make sense and the repair history you built does not vanish. Unit level records export, so the two years of dated tickets on a 1960s building move with you into whatever you adopt next.